How to Build Web Forms: Five Methods Compared
Web forms are where your prospects become your leads. All your ambitious advertising campaigns, lovingly crafted landing pages, strategic SEO efforts and compelling content, finally pay off when that form gets filled in. As such it’s really, really important to get them right.
Consider this: If your average lead value is £500, your landing page attracts 1000 visitors a day, and your web conversion rate is 4%. A dip in conversion rate to 3% would equate to a £5000 daily loss. Despite this, we marketers rarely give the humble web form much thought, we make do with the platform or method that was being used by our company when we started. And if that makes you curious about: how are other people doing it? Or, what if there is a much, much better way? To get started, here is how most organisations build and manage their web forms today, and what each approach costs you in practice.
Web form build methods compared
Five ways to build and manage web forms, what each is genuinely good for, and the limitation that tends to decide against it at scale.
| Method | Best for | Main limitation | Developer needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marketing automation platform | Teams already standardised on one MAP who need native tracking | Form building is manual and embeds are static, so every change is a round trip | For embedding and any change to it |
| CMS plugin | Single-site builds where the form rarely changes | Forms live per site, so a multi-site estate drifts out of step | Occasionally, for anything beyond the default |
| Dedicated form builder | Fast standalone forms and quick campaigns | Governance and compliance wording are set form by form | Rarely |
| Bespoke build | Highly specific flows nothing off the shelf can do | Cost and maintenance sit with you permanently | Always |
| Template-based governed platform | Estates where the same form runs across sites, brands and regions | Needs a one-off setup to define the templates | No, after setup |
Marketing Automation Platforms
Eloqua, Marketo, Pardo, Hubspot
Large enterprises commonly leverage the native web forms integrated into their Marketing Automation Platforms (MAPs). Due to their inherent connection with the platform it does make tracking and reporting a bit easier, but they suffer from being outdated, cumbersome, and feature-light. The process of creating forms is largely manual and requires significant effort from your marketing team.
When using a MAP, forms are embedded on your website using static HTML or Scripts. Consequently, any modification to a form mandates a tedious cycle—return to the MAP, implement changes, retrieve the HTML, and update the web page. This labor-intensive procedure will be repeated for every single change, for every single web form, on every single page, AKA Snoozeville, Population: a few hundred thousand interns.
Content Management Software
Drupal, WordPress, Wix, Squarespace, Sitecore
A Content Management Systems (CMS) primarily focuses on content management but can integrate web forms into their templates. Most CMSs will come with a basic built-in form component, but unless you only need a simple contact form, they are unlikely to have the features and connectivity required to be anything other than a hindrance. CMSs get around this by offering a marketplace of plugins and extensions with varied levels of functionality, customisation, connectivity and cost.
Form Builders
Form.io, FormStack, JotForm, 123FormBuilder, TypeForm
Dedicated form builder platforms are specifically designed for the creation of lead forms, surveys, and feedback forms. Unlike MAPs or CMSs, form builders generally provide a more extensive array of form-related features and a much cleaner UX. Additionally, they offer a broader range of integrations and APIs so you can connect with other marketing tools. It’s worth noting that (as the name suggests), form builders place a primary emphasis on the creation of forms, with comparatively less focus on comprehensive form management. So with form builders you’re going to have a lot more templates and designs to choose from, they are also going to be easier to build and provide a better experience for your web users. However, large enterprises are going to struggle with management across regional marketing teams and data governance (getting the right data to the right place in the right format) will be a challenge.
Bespoke
The DIY Approach
So you’ve had a look around and nothing quite fits the bill, why not build them yourself? Bespoke or DIY web forms involve custom development by your in-house (or outsourced) web team from scratch. It is by far the most flexible approach but it is also the most resource-intensive. While this does give you complete control over form design and functionality you’re going to have to keep going back to the developers for ongoing support, updates and maintenance. With the average day rate of a digital project manager or senior web developer being £500+, this is an expensive option.
What is the best way to build web forms?
Herein lies the frustration, none of these options feel like a win, they all have drawbacks. MAPs and CMSs treat forms like an afterthought and prove to be tedious to build and manage. On the other hand form builders excel in aesthetics but often lack the tailored marketing focus and robust tools needed for enterprise-level form management and data governance. As for the DIY approach, it’s a formidable task that proves too burdensome for most companies to entertain. This is exactly why we built Formulayt, the humble web form is finally getting the attention it deserves, here’s how…
The Formulayt Approach
- Formulayt is the only form solution that gives control of form deployment and data governance to marketing teams.
- Forms are created using our Smart Templates that are actively connected to forms even after they are deployed to your website.
- Marketers can define their data capture standards and make ongoing tweaks to them even after forms are live.
- Each form has its own meta-data or hidden values for data driven workflows whilst still inheriting from the Smart Templates.
- Forms are automatically monitored for performance and to log where they are being used in your site.
- Deploying forms into a site does not involve any technical skill or integration. Marketers embed forms into pages using a simple hyperlink.
- The system is packed with built-in no-code solutions for digital marketers such as pre-population, progressive profiling, dynamic fields, attribution capture, blind submits, geo-location, marketing consent and more.
- To find out more request a demo.
Frequently asked questions
How do you build a web form?
There are five routes: the form builder inside a marketing automation platform, a CMS plugin, a dedicated form builder, a bespoke build, or a governed platform that builds every form from a central template. The right one depends less on the form itself and more on how many of them you will end up running, and who has to change them.
How do you build the same form across several websites?
Natively, you rebuild or clone it per site, and from that point each copy drifts. A governed template keeps one definition and inherits it everywhere, so a change to a field, a validation rule or a consent line is made once rather than site by site.
Do you need a developer to build a web form?
For most methods, yes, at least for embedding and for any change to the embed afterwards. A platform that deploys forms by hyperlink rather than by script removes that dependency, so marketing can publish and change a form without a release.
What is the difference between a form builder and a form management platform?
A form builder makes an individual form quickly. A form management platform governs an estate of them: shared field definitions, consent wording set per region, and performance visible in one place. If you have a handful of forms, the first is enough. If you have hundreds, the second is what stops them diverging.
How long does it take to build a web form?
A single form takes minutes on any of these methods. What takes time is everything after it: embedding it, changing it later, keeping it consistent with the others and evidencing consent. That is where the methods separate, not at the build. The Formulayt Approach